BC.Game Pays $1.9M After Biased Shuffle Found in Video Poker

BC.Game has taken its Video Poker and single player Baccarat games offline after an investigation found the games' card shuffle lowered player returns for more than six years. It says it will pay around $1.9 million to players as compensation.

BC.Game Pays $1.9M After Biased Shuffle Found in Video Poker

Marcos Miguel

· 2 min

On Nov. 17, ProvablyFair.org found that BC.Game’s Video Poker had a house edge of about 3.6%, almost double the advertised 2%. For every $10,000 wagered, players could expect to lose about $360 instead of $200, according to the report.

How the shuffle worked

ProvablyFair.org found that BC.Game’s shuffle held some cards together, making them land in the same hand more often than they should have. The bias made strong starting hands rarer, leading to royal flushes coming up 19.1% less often than with a fair shuffle.

Every hand ProvablyFair.org played still passed BC.Game's provably fair check. However, the check only shows that a game follows its published method, not that the method used is itself fair.

ProvablyFair.org played 62 real money hands of Video Poker and 150 rounds of Baccarat, and all of them matched BC.Game's published verifier. It then simulated 600 million Video Poker deals to work out the real return.

The same shuffle was also used in single player Baccarat, where the Player Pair bet returned about 77.1% instead of 80.8%, according to the report.

BC.Game confirms the bias

On Nov. 19, BC.Game CEO Ako confirmed the bias in a post on X. "Our investigation has confirmed that the shuffle algorithm used in both games contains a bias that affects game outcomes and player returns," he wrote.

According to the CEO, the shuffle was built in house in 2018, and at first it actually favored players. In 2020, BC.Game changed the deck's starting order after spotting "irregularities", which led to the bias being turned against players, his statement says.

The report dates the change to April 8, 2020, when the return on the paytable then in use dropped from about 102.6% to about 97.3%.

$1.9M in compensation

On Nov. 19, BC.Game’s CEO said it will pay 1,779,578 USDT to 576,782 Video Poker accounts, as well as 136,577 USDT going to 142,267 Baccarat accounts.

The amounts are based on each player's wagers and work out to about $3 per Video Poker account on average. The compensation is paid as a bonus with no wagering requirements, which means players can withdraw it straight away.

ProvablyFair.org said on Nov. 19 that it had not yet seen the compensation on its own account. Later that day, BC.Game’s CEO said all affected players had been notified and compensated.

What is still unclear

BC.Game has not said whether the compensation covers bets placed since 2020, or only recent play. The report found the bias on every Video Poker paytable BC.Game has used, including a 99% version and a 96% version.

BC.Game says Keno, Mines, Patti, StellarRush and its multiplayer Baccarat use a different shuffle, which showed no bias in its own tests. It is now replacing the shuffle in Video Poker and single player Baccarat with one based on its Bingo draw.

Treat gambling as entertainment you pay for. 18+, and if it stops feeling like entertainment, help exists at BeGambleAware and GamCare.

Read More Articles

See more